First off. I wouldn't use Pink noise to check output levels of an amplifier. There's just too much going on to get an accurate reading.
Second. What are you measuring the voltage with? It really doesn't surprise me that the pink noise had a lower output on a simple voltmeter.
Third. I wouldn't trust tones downloaded from anywhere unless I verified the tone to be true to the frequency and actually at 0db.
If you know somebody that has an o-scope, hook that up and see what the peak to peak voltage is using a good commercial CD with a true 1khz 0db tone and a true 50hz 0db tone.
As for this statement
got to remember when you got flat line on a rta it does not sound best but is what your shooting for in a sq match. it should be with in 3 dbs of all the bars next to each other
That's true when you are running the system in something like a RTA freq out event. That's not what any of us use in real sound quality competitions. My RTA curve used in judging is FAR from flat. I can't say I've ever used a rta to measure amp output anyway. I would be interested in hearing that method. Or maybe I just mis-understood something.